Setas rellenas
Large mushroom caps stuffed with a secret Basque cheese blend and baked in a wine sauce. The dish people drove out of their way for.
La Cocina Vasca
A Basque menu is a set of habits as much as a list of dishes: shellfish cooked hard and fast in olive oil and garlic, rice coloured with saffron, sauces carried by sherry and Jerez wine, and a long table that nobody is in a hurry to leave.
Jai-Alai Restaurant closed permanently after the fire of September 2023. This page explains the dishes as the restaurant served them; the full menu with prices is here.
Start here
Chances are you have heard of the stuffed mushrooms. Of all the dishes featured at the Jai Alai, the famous appetizer was certainly the most popular — and the most mysterious. People travelled many miles to sample it, and to beg Nick for his secret recipe. He would only ever say that three cheeses were involved.
What the menu card confirms is the method: large mushroom caps stuffed with a secret Basque cheese blend and baked in a wine sauce, served as setas rellenas at $13.00. No meal at the Jai Alai was considered complete without them for starters.
Large mushroom caps stuffed with a secret Basque cheese blend and baked in a wine sauce. The dish people drove out of their way for.
The classic Basque paella, named for Bizkaia: fresh lobster, shrimp, scallops, clams, mussels, squid, chicken and chorizo over saffron rice, for two or more.
Red or white, made in house with no sugar added, sold by the half pitcher and the full pitcher. The reviewer from dover_nj.com called it superb either way.